Articles

Analog or Digital? How to Connect the Source to the DAC

When connecting a streamer or CD player to your amplifier, one of the most common questions is: Is it better to use an analog or digital connection? There is no one-size-fits-all answer, because it depends primarily on a key component of the hi-fi system: the DAC—the converter that transforms the digital signal into an analog signal that the amplifier can use. Understanding where this conversion takes place is the first step in choosing the connection that best suits your system.

The key question: Which DAC do we want to use?

A CD player or streamer equipped with RCA or XLR outputs necessarily has a built-in DAC. If we use these outputs, the device performs the digital-to-analog conversion internally and sends an analog signal to the amplifier. If, on the other hand, we use a digital output, the signal is transferred without being converted, and the DAC downstream—such as the one built into the amplifier or a dedicated external DAC—will handle the conversion.
We can therefore summarize the concept very simply: when using RCA or XLR analog outputs, we rely on the streamer’s or CD player’s DAC; when using a digital connection, however, we rely on the amplifier’s DAC or an external DAC for the conversion. Consequently, the first question to ask shouldn’t simply be, “Is analog or digital better?” but rather, “Which DAC is best in my system?”

Analog connection: RCA or XLR

If we believe the source’s internal DAC is superior, the best choice is an analog connection. The most common connections are RCA and balanced XLR. RCA is the most widely used analog connection in the Hi-Fi world and is found on virtually every amplifier. XLR, on the other hand, uses balanced transmission and is typically available on mid-to-high-end and high-end equipment. However, we shouldn’t assume that XLR necessarily sounds better than RCA. Much depends on how the input and output stages of the two devices are designed. If both devices feature truly balanced circuitry, XLR can be a particularly attractive option.

Digital connectivity: plenty of options to choose from

If we want to use the amplifier's DAC or an external converter, we need to convert the signal to digital. There are many options:

  • Coaxial S/PDIF: widely used on CD players, streamers, DACs, and amplifiers;
  • TOSLINK optical connection: uses optical fiber and ensures electrical isolation between electronic components;
  • USB audio: particularly common in computers, streamers, and DACs;
  • AES/EBU: a balanced digital connection, widely used in professional settings and also found on many high-end Hi-Fi systems;
  • I²S: increasingly common on modern sources and DACs, often via an HDMI connection. It’s important to remember that, unlike traditional HDMI audio-video, there is no universal pinout standard; it is therefore necessary to verify compatibility between the two devices.

However, the presence of a more sophisticated connection does not automatically mean it will sound the best. The implementation of the interfaces, the design of the electronics, and the quality of the DAC can significantly affect the final result.

Three Possible Setups for Streamers and CD Players

There are three main setups to consider. If the best DAC is the one in the streamer or CD player, the source will handle the digital-to-analog conversion. In this case, the signal will reach the amplifier via an analog RCA or XLR connection.
If, on the other hand, we consider the amplifier’s built-in DAC to be superior, it’s best to keep the signal in digital form all the way to the amplifier, using one of the available connections, such as coaxial, optical, USB, AES/EBU, or I²S.
The third option is to use a dedicated external DAC. In this case, the streamer or CD player will send the digital signal to the DAC, which will perform the conversion; from the DAC, the signal will then continue in analog form, via RCA or XLR, to the amplifier.
These are three different paths for the same signal, and understanding them helps us determine which component of our Hi-Fi system we want to entrust with the delicate digital-to-analog conversion.

The simplest test? Try both solutions.

In a hi-fi system, a hands-on test is often much more useful than any purely theoretical consideration. If our streamer or CD player has both analog and digital outputs and the amplifier has a built-in DAC, we can conduct a very interesting comparison. Ideally, we should use cables from the same manufacturer and/or of comparable quality. For example, we can simultaneously connect the source to the amplifier using an analog RCA or XLR cable and a digital coaxial, AES/EBU, or other compatible cable. At this point, simply play the same track and switch inputs on the amplifier.
With the analog connection, we’ll hear the sound produced by the source’s DAC; when switching to the digital input, we’ll hear the sound produced by the amplifier’s DAC. We can thus compare the two signal paths almost in real time, without having to constantly disconnect and reconnect the cables. However, one small precaution is important. It’s advisable to ensure that the volume levels of the two configurations are as similar as possible. Even a small difference can, in fact, affect perception and make the solution that simply sounds louder seem better.

Conclusion

The point is that there is no single answer that applies to every system. Two devices may use different converters, but they may also have very different output stages, power supplies, and implementations of digital interfaces. For this reason, relying solely on technical specifications does not always allow you to predict which connection will deliver the most satisfying result.
Furthermore, one technology should not be considered superior to another in absolute terms. An excellent analog connection may be preferable to a digital one in a given system, while changing the DAC, streamer, CD player, or amplifier could yield a completely different result.
Whenever possible, the advice is therefore to try both configurations. A good analog cable and a digital cable of equivalent quality allow you to make a direct comparison and determine which DAC and which signal path integrate best with your system. Because in Hi-Fi, ultimately, the best solution is the one that allows your system to perform at its best.
Whether you choose an analog RCA or XLR connection, or a digital connection such as coaxial, USB, AES/EBU, HDMI, or I²S, the quality of the connection helps ensure that every component in the system can perform at its best. In the Ricable catalog, you’ll find analog and digital cables at various price points, designed to help you choose the best solution for any streamer, CD player, DAC, and amplifier—and, why not, to directly test the different configurations of your Hi-Fi system.

Leave a comment